Head to head · Air exchangers

HRV or ERV: what difference for your home? Two Lifebreath air exchangers compared

8 min
Comparison · Guide · HRV or ERV

HRV or ERV: heat crosses in both, moisture in only one

An HRV (heat recovery ventilator) and an ERV (energy recovery ventilator) renew the house air the same way: a stale airstream goes out, an outdoor airstream comes in, and the two cross in a core without mixing. The difference is the core. The HRV's lets heat through; the ERV's lets heat and part of the water vapour through. To see it in numbers, this page compares two units from the same manufacturer sold by AirGreen and listed in the HVI directory.

HRV · net moisture transfer 0.00ERV · net moisture transfer 0.45Summer test (35 °C) · ERV onlyHVI directory, section III
HRV · heat recovery Lifebreath RNC 155 air exchanger (HRV), AirGreen product card LIFEBREATH

RNC 155

HRV · HVID 2505086 · 138 cfm at 0.4 in. w.g.

See the product page
ERV · energy recovery Lifebreath 130 ERVD air exchanger (ERV), AirGreen product card LIFEBREATH

130 ERVD

ERV · HVID 2005554 · 144 cfm at 0.4 in. w.g.

See the product page

Article published November 21, 2025 · updated November 17, 2026

Estimated running cost

What their fans cost, in dollars per year

AirGreen estimate at Hydro-Québec Rate D, taxes included, from the power the HVI directory publishes for each test point. The two units are not tested at the same airflow: each button shows its own.

Price per kWh (Rate D, April 1, 2026)
RNC 155 HRV: HVI test point
130 ERVD ERV: HVI test point
How this amount is calculated
  1. Electricity = published power (W) × hours per day × 365 days ÷ 1,000.
  2. Power: HVI certified directory, section III, “Power Consumed” column, for each test point: RNC 155 (HVID 2505086) 72 W at 64 cfm and 92 W at 68 cfm (−25 °C); 130 ERVD (HVID 2005554) 80 W at 89 cfm, 99 W at 110 cfm, 96 W at 78 cfm (−25 °C) and 78 W at 83 cfm (35 °C).
  3. Not counted: heating and cooling the incoming outdoor air, defrost and the wall control.
  4. Price: Hydro-Québec Rate D in force April 1, 2026 (7.065 ¢ up to 40 kWh per day, 11.142 ¢ above, average 9.104 ¢), × 1.14975 for GST and QST; network access charges not counted.

AirGreen method v1.1, ventilation, November 9, 2026. An estimate is for comparing units under the same conditions. The actual bill depends on the building, the settings and the use; this amount is not a promise.

Where the moisture goes

Twenty drops go out: how many come back?

For each test the HVI directory publishes a net moisture transfer (NMT) measured under CSA C439. At 0, the core passes no moisture from one airstream to the other. Pick the unit and the season: the diagram replays the test with twenty drops, rounding the published ratio.

water vapour that keeps its pathwater vapour that crosses the corecoreDiagram; the drops illustrate the published NMT ratio, rounded to the twentieth.
Four situations

Your house, and the number that concerns it

The choice between HRV and ERV depends on what happens in the house. For each situation, here is the published value that relates to it; the decision stays yours, with the estimator on site.

Moisture going outFogged windows in winter

The RNC 155 HRV publishes a net moisture transfer of 0.00 at 0 °C: the vapour in the outgoing air goes outside. The 130 ERVD ERV publishes 0.45: part of it comes back in the fresh air. When the goal is to move moisture out of the house in winter, that is the number that matters.

Moisture that staysVery dry indoor air in winter

The same number reads the other way: at 0.45 the ERV returns to the house part of the vapour the outgoing air would carry away. The HRV, at 0.00, returns none. Neither adds water: they move what is already in the air.

35 °C testHumid summer, air-conditioned house

Only the 130 ERVD ERV has a summer test in the HVI directory: at 35 °C, net moisture transfer of 0.43 and total recovery efficiency (TRE) of 49% at 83 cfm. The directory publishes no summer test for the RNC 155 HRV.

Heat recoveredWinter at −25 °C

At −25 °C the directory publishes 70% sensible recovery for the HRV (68 cfm, 92 W) and 65% for the ERV (78 cfm, 96 W). The test airflows differ: both numbers are exact, each for its own test.

In deep cold

0 °C and −25 °C: what each test publishes

The HVI directory tests units at 0 °C and −25 °C. The bars show the sensible recovery (SRE) of each published test, with its airflow and power. No value is drawn between two tests.

Sensible recovery efficiency (SRE): share of the outgoing air's heat passed to the fresh air, with motors and leakage counted, per CSA C439. Each bar is one HVI test, with its airflow and power; the bars are not joined to each other.

HVI sheet

Both units, line by line

All values come from the HVI certified directory, section III (data of November 4, 2026). The tests are not made at the same airflows: no line is marked “higher”.

FeatureLIFEBREATH RNC 155 · HRVLIFEBREATH 130 ERVD · ERV
Airflow
Net fresh airflow at 0.1 in. w.g.170 cfmHVI 2505086172 cfmHVI 2005554
Net fresh airflow at 0.4 in. w.g.138 cfmHVI 2505086144 cfmHVI 2005554
Winter, 0 °C
Sensible recovery (SRE)75% at 64 cfmHVI 250508675% at 89 cfm; 73% at 110 cfmHVI 2005554
Apparent sensible effectiveness (ASRE)82%HVI 250508681%; 79%HVI 2005554
Net moisture transfer (NMT)0.00HVI 25050860.45 at 89 cfm; 0.42 at 110 cfmHVI 2005554
Power consumed72 WHVI 250508680 W; 99 WHVI 2005554
Deep cold, −25 °C
Sensible recovery (SRE) at −25 °C70% at 68 cfmHVI 250508665% at 78 cfmHVI 2005554
Net moisture transfer at −25 °C0.05HVI 25050860.44HVI 2005554
Power consumed at −25 °C92 WHVI 250508696 WHVI 2005554
Summer, 35 °C
Cooling testNo cooling test in the HVI directoryHVI 250508683 cfm, 78 W; net moisture transfer 0.43; total recovery (TRE) 49%HVI 2005554
Identification
Directory categoryHRV, 120 VHVI 2505086ERV, 120 VHVI 2005554
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is an ERV a dehumidifier?

No. An ERV does not remove water from the house air: its core passes part of the vapour from one airstream to the other. In winter it returns part of it to the house; in summer it lets less of it in. The HVI directory quantifies this with the net moisture transfer.

What is net moisture transfer (NMT)?

It is a ratio HVI publishes for each test, per CSA C439. The closer it is to 0, the less water vapour the core passes between the outgoing and incoming air. The RNC 155 publishes 0.00 at 0 °C and the 130 ERVD 0.45.

Why aren't the test airflows the same?

Each manufacturer has its units tested at the airflows it chooses. The RNC 155 is tested at 64 and 68 cfm; the 130 ERVD at 78, 83, 89 and 110 cfm. The page shows each value with its airflow and marks none as higher.

Does the HRV run in summer?

Yes, it keeps renewing the air. The HVI directory publishes no summer test for the RNC 155, so this page gives it no figure at 35 °C.

Why two units of the same brand?

So that the difference between them comes mostly from the core. The RNC 155 and the 130 ERVD are two Lifebreath exchangers sold by AirGreen, with close airflows (138 and 144 cfm at 0.4 in. w.g.).

Another page already compares an HRV and an ERV. Which one should I read?

The “HRV or ERV: vänEE V160H75RT and V160E75RT” page shows a cut through the core in winter and summer. This one follows moisture from one test to the next, with two Lifebreath units. They complement each other.

Both are on the AirGreen website.

The estimator looks at the house, the windows in winter, the air conditioning and the ducts before proposing an HRV or an ERV.

Sources

Documents consulted

HVI Certified Products Directory, section III (HRV/ERV)HVI Publication 911, data as of November 4, 2026, read November 17, 2026 · LIFEBREATH RNC155, HVID 2505086 · LIFEBREATH 130ERVD, HVID 2005554 (model sheets: airflows, energy tests)
CSA C439, HRV/ERV test methodstandard cited by HVI for the published tests
Hydro-Québec, Electricity RatesApril 1, 2026, Rate D, art. 2.5 · read November 17, 2026

Further reading

You made it to the end.Share it with someone it could help.

2 comments

Michel Deschenes
Michel Deschenes

Je désire changer mon échangeur d’air Direct Air VRC pour un bon VRE afin de controler l’humidité car c’est très sec en hiver. Maison de deux étages à Terrebonne, QC.

André Potvin
André Potvin

Bonjour, je cherche un remplacement pour mon échangeur d’air Venmar HEPA3100.
Que proposez-vous et à quel prix? Merci!

Leave a comment