Heat pump or electric water heater in Québec

Home / Comparisons / Guides

Guide · Water heaters · Québec

Heat pump or electric water heater in Québec

An electric water heater heats water with elements immersed in the tank. A heat pump water heater first takes heat from the air of the room it stands in, and keeps elements as backup. This guide shows where that heat comes from, what it changes in a Québec basement in winter, and what the unit needs: space, a volume of air and a drain.

Heat pump: heat taken from room airElectric: heat from immersed elementsRoom asked for by the example: 19.8 m³ or moreHeat pump running: air between 2 and 49 °C
BRADFORD WHITE AeroTherm RE2H50S10, example of a heat pump water heater (AirGreen image)
Heat pump example

BRADFORD WHITE AeroTherm RE2H50S10

RE2H50S10-1NCTT · 240 V · 189 L

Spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA, July 2025

See the product page
BRADFORD WHITE RE250T6, example of an electric water heater (AirGreen image)
Electric example

BRADFORD WHITE RE250T6

RE250T6-1NCPP · 240 V · 178 L

Spec sheet C1201-0926 CANADA, September 2026

See the product page
What heats the water in each example, at 240 V
Heat pump example
Compressor
500 W
Element, as backup
4,000 W
Electric example
Element
4,500 W
Heat taken from the basement air

Where the heat comes from, and where the cooled air goes

In both cases the water heats in a tank. The difference is where the heat comes from. Pick the type of unit and the season, then move the room air temperature.

492123456712345Diagram

Heat pump example: what its manual prints

BRADFORD WHITE AeroTherm RE2H50S10

  1. Room air enters through the top of the unit, across a washable filter.Manual 238-52169-00C
  2. At least 20.3 cm (8 in) clear above, to remove the filter.Manual 238-52169-00C
  3. The air leaves at the rear, cooled. If the room air drops by more than 8 °C (15 °F) during heating, the manual considers air circulation insufficient and points to a ducting kit.Manual 238-52169-00C
  4. Condensate leaves through a 3/4 in fitting to a drain no higher than 91.4 cm (36 in) above the floor. With no drain, a condensate pump of at least 3.8 L per day.Manual 238-52169-00C
  5. Room of 19.8 m³ (700 ft³) or more. Otherwise: a louvered door with 0.15 m² (240 in²) of open area, or a ducting kit.Manual 238-52169-00C
  6. The heat pump runs when room air is between 2 and 49 °C. Outside that range, the electric elements take over.Spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA; Manual 238-52169-00C
  7. 17.5 cm (7 in) recommended at the rear and on the right side; the rear must not discharge against a wall.Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric example: what its manual prints

BRADFORD WHITE RE250T6

  1. Two 4,500 W immersed elements heat the water, one at a time.Spec sheet C1201-0926 CANADA
  2. 45.7 cm (18 in) recommended above and 61 cm (24 in) in front, for servicing. Minimum clearance to combustible material: 0 in.Manual 238-44422-00Z
  3. The manual asks for neither an air volume nor a condensate drain: the unit does not exchange air with the room to heat.Manual 238-44422-00Z
  4. Where a leak would cause damage: a drain pan at least 10.2 cm (4 in) wider than the diameter, piped to a drain.Manual 238-44422-00Z
  5. Level floor, protected from freezing, close to a power supply and the water lines.Manual 238-44422-00Z
In winter. With a heat pump water heater, the heat removed from the basement air has to be made up by the home's heating if the same temperature is to be kept there. Natural Resources Canada writes that heat pump water heaters are less advantageous in winter, when space heating is required. The example's Electric (Only) mode heats with no fan and no cool air discharged; its manual describes it as the least energy-efficient. An electric water heater takes nothing from the room air.
In summer. With a heat pump water heater, the heat removed from the air of the home lowers cooling needs, and the unit also removes humidity, according to Natural Resources Canada's water heater guide. That humidity becomes the condensate that runs to the drain. An electric water heater changes neither the temperature nor the humidity of the room in order to heat.

Diagram drawn to scale for the heights and diameters of the two examples (spec sheets); the room itself is illustrative. Operation and requirements: BRADFORD WHITE manuals 238-52169-00C and 238-44422-00Z. Context: Natural Resources Canada, “Guide sur les chauffe-eau” (Water Heater Guide), p. 15.

What it needs

Space, air and a drain

The electric example's manual asks for no air volume. A heat pump water heater, for its part, needs air around it: that is its heat source. The example's manual gives a figure for the room volume; check yours.

Does your room have the required volume?

Threshold: 700 ft³ (19.8 m³), that is 10 × 10 × 7 ft, BRADFORD WHITE manual 238-52169-00C. Conversion: 1 ft³ = 0.0283 m³. The multiplication is AirGreen's; it does not replace an on-site check.
Room volume

Heat pump example19.8 m³ (700 ft³) or more. Below that: a louvered door or two louvered sections, with 0.15 m² (240 in²) of open area, or a ducting kit (23 m of duct at most, inlet and outlet combined). Manual 238-52169-00C; Spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA

Electric exampleNo air volume asked for by the manual. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Clearances

Heat pump example17.5 cm (7 in) recommended at the rear and on the right side; 20.3 cm (8 in) above for the filter; clear front. A confined space increases the use of the elements, per the manual. Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric exampleMinimum clearance of 0 in to combustible material; 45.7 cm (18 in) above and 61 cm (24 in) in front recommended for servicing. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Condensate and drain

Heat pump example3/4 in condensate fitting; a floor drain or one no higher than 91.4 cm (36 in), with a continuous slope. With no drain: a condensate pump of at least 3.8 L per day. Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric exampleNo condensate: the unit does not remove humidity from the air. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Ambient air: the heat pump's range

Heat pump example2 to 49 °C (35 to 120 °F). Outside that range, the heat pump stops and the elements heat until the air is back within range. Spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA; Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric exampleNo ambient air range for heating; the unit and its piping must stay protected from freezing. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Air filter

Heat pump exampleWashable filter on top; a light and an alarm signal when to clean it. If it gets too dirty, the unit switches to Electric (Only) mode. Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric exampleNo air filter. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Drain pan

Heat pump exampleWhere a leak would cause damage: a pan at least 10.2 cm (4 in) larger than the base diameter. Manual 238-52169-00C

Electric exampleSame requirement: at least 10.2 cm (4 in) wider than the diameter, piped to a drain. Manual 238-44422-00Z

Hot water

A comparable first hour, a slower recovery on the compressor alone

The two examples have tanks in the same class: 189 L and 178 L. Their first-hour ratings are close, 246 L and 242 L. The gap is in recovery: on the compressor alone, the heat pump example reheats 23 L per hour; the electric example, 79 L per hour.

Litres reheated per hour, for a 50 °C rise

Heat pump, compressor only23 L/h
189 L ÷ 23 L/h ≈ 8.2 h for the whole tank
Heat pump, compressor and element91 L/h
189 L ÷ 91 L/h ≈ 2.1 h for the whole tank
Electric, one 4,500 W element79 L/h
178 L ÷ 79 L/h ≈ 2.3 h for the whole tank
Recovery: BRADFORD WHITE spec sheets C1902-0725 CANADA (Hybrid mode, ambient air at 19.7 °C (67.5 °F), 50% relative humidity) and C1201-0926 CANADA (4,500 W, one element at a time). The durations are AirGreen's divisions, as an order of magnitude.

The modes of the heat pump example

The unit picks its heat source according to the mode. The electric example has only one way of heating.

CompressorElementsCool air discharged into the room
Spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA; Manual 238-52169-00C
Efficiency

One certified figure, and the conditions under which it is measured

The heat pump of a heat pump water heater does not turn electricity into heat: it uses it to move heat from the air to the water. Its efficiency is expressed by the Uniform Energy Factor (UEF). In Canada, that of an electric storage water heater is instead expressed by its standby loss, in watts.

Heat pump example

UEF of 3.44: for 1 part of electricity, 3.44 parts of heat in the water delivered

UEF of 3.44: spec sheet C1902-0725 CANADA, from the AHRI directory. The manual states that reported consumption is based on Hybrid mode, non-ducted, at US Department of Energy test conditions. The share taken from the air (3.44 − 1 = 2.44, at least) is an energy balance worked out by AirGreen.
Electric example

Standby loss of 63 W; UEF not published on the Canadian spec sheet

Standby loss of 63 W: spec sheet C1201-0926 CANADA. Natural Resources Canada explains that the efficiency of electric storage water heaters is expressed as standby loss, in watts (“Guide sur les chauffe-eau”, p. 7). An element delivers no more heat than the electricity it uses.
Why this page has no “Cost per season” section. The UEF is established at the conditions of the standard test, and the documents consulted put no figure on what the heat taken from basement air adds to the heating of a Québec home in winter. An annual estimate in dollars would therefore rest on assumptions that nothing certifies: this page gives none and promises no amount.
What Natural Resources Canada says. Its guide describes the heat pump water heater as potentially cost-effective in milder climates, and less advantageous in winter when rooms are heated. Its ENERGY STAR page notes that the heat is taken from the air of the basement or utility room, sometimes from outside.
The two examples

Two units of the same brand, side by side

To compare types rather than brands, both examples come from the same manufacturer and the same tank class, known as 50 US gallons. They are almost the same height; the heat pump example also asks for 20.3 cm clear above it. Both are sold by AirGreen. Other models exist in each type.

BRADFORD WHITE AeroTherm RE2H50S10, manufacturer photo, cut out
Heat pump example59 3/16 in tallAeroTherm RE2H50S10 · 21 3/4 in diameter · 195 lb (88 kg)
BRADFORD WHITE RE250T6, manufacturer photo, cut out
Electric example59 in tallRE250T6 · 20 in diameter · 130 lb (59 kg)

Manufacturer photos shown at the same height scale. Their width depends on the camera angle: for the diameter, rely on the listed dimensions.

MeasureHeat pump example · AeroTherm RE2H50S10Electric example · RE250T6
Tank
Tank volume189 L50 US gal, 42 imp. gal178 L47 US gal, 39 imp. gal
Diameter × overall height21 3/4 in × 59 3/16 in552 × 1,503 mm20 in × 59 in508 × 1,499 mm
Shipping weight195 lb88 kg130 lb59 kg
What heats
Compressor500 WNot applicableno heat pump
Heating elements2 × 4,000 W at 240 V3,000 W at 208 V; one at a time2 × 4,500 W at 240 Vone at a time
RefrigerantR-134a29.1 ozNot applicable
Hot water
First-hour rating246 L65 US gal242 L64 US gal
Recovery at a 50 °C rise23 L/h, compressor only91 L/h, compressor and element79 L/h
Efficiency
Uniform Energy Factor (UEF)3.44Not published by the manufacturerCanadian spec sheet
Standby lossNot published by the manufacturer63 W
Settings and sound
Factory temperature setting49 °C120 °F, Hybrid mode; adjustable from 38 to 60 °C60 °C140 °F, in Canada
Sound levelNot published by the manufacturerthe manual mentions a fan that can be heard when runningNot published by the manufacturer
Electrical and plumbing
Voltage240 V or 208 V240 Vfactory wiring; other voltages to order
Recommended breaker25 A minimum25 Arecommended fuse for 4,500 W at 240 V
Water connections3/4 in NPT3/4 in NPT
Documents
Spec sheetC1902-0725 CANADAJuly 2025C1201-0926 CANADASeptember 2026
Installation manual238-52169-00CFebruary 2022238-44422-00ZJanuary 2024
In Québec: 60 °C in the tank. Chapter III, Plumbing, of the Québec Construction Code requires that water stored in a water heater be at no less than 60 °C (article 2.6.1.12, edition in force since July 11, 2024, per the explanatory booklet of the Régie du bâtiment du Québec). The factory setting of the heat pump example is 49 °C, adjustable up to 60 °C; it is checked at installation. Information noted on November 10, 2026, which can change; this is not advice.
Licensed work. Wiring, plumbing and the condensate drain of a water heater are work for licensed trades. The values above are those of the spec sheets and manuals; they replace neither the rating plate nor the codes in force.
Questions

What people ask before choosing

Does a heat pump water heater cool the basement?

Yes, when the heat pump runs: it takes heat from the air and discharges cooled air. The example's manual states that if the room air drops by more than 8 °C during heating, air circulation is insufficient and a ducting kit can direct the cold air elsewhere.

Does it work in a cold basement?

The example's heat pump runs when room air is between 2 and 49 °C. Outside that range it stops and the electric elements heat the water until the air is back within range.

Is it advantageous in winter in Québec?

Natural Resources Canada writes that heat pump water heaters are less advantageous in winter, when rooms have to be heated, and that they can be cost-effective in milder climates. This page puts no figure on it: the documents consulted do not measure that case for a Québec home.

Is a drain needed?

Yes for the heat pump example: the humidity removed from the air runs through a 3/4 in fitting to a drain no higher than 91.4 cm above the floor. With no drain, the manual calls for a condensate pump of at least 3.8 L per day. The electric example produces no condensate.

How big a room is needed?

The example's manual asks for 19.8 m³ (700 ft³), that is a 10 ft by 10 ft room with a 7 ft ceiling. In a smaller room, it calls for a louvered door with 0.15 m² of open area, two louvered sections, or a ducting kit.

Will I have less hot water?

The first-hour ratings of the two examples are close: 246 L for the heat pump unit, 242 L for the electric one. Recovery differs: 23 L per hour on the compressor alone, 91 L per hour with the compressor and an element, 79 L per hour for the electric example.

Is it noisy?

The heat pump example's manual says a fan can be heard when the heat pump runs; it publishes no sound level. The electric example has no fan.

Why does this page not compare warranties?

A warranty has to be read in full, with its conditions and exclusions. Each unit's warranty documents are provided with the quote.

Both are on the AirGreen site.

To find out which one suits your home, talk it over with our team: the room, the drain, the electrical circuit and your hot water habits matter as much as the figures.

Sources and documents

Where each figure comes from

BRADFORD WHITE, AeroTherm spec sheetC1902-0725 CANADA, July 2025 · volume, first-hour rating, UEF, recovery, dimensions, modes, ambient air range · consulted on November 10, 2026
BRADFORD WHITE, AeroTherm manual238-52169-00C, effective February 2022 · room volume, clearances, condensate, modes, factory setting, compressor, breaker · consulted on November 10, 2026
BRADFORD WHITE, residential electric spec sheetC1201-0926 CANADA, September 2026 · volume, first-hour rating, standby loss, recovery, dimensions · consulted on November 10, 2026
BRADFORD WHITE, electric water heater manual238-44422-00Z, rev. 01/24 · location, clearances, drain pan, recommended fuse, 60 °C setting in Canada · consulted on November 10, 2026
Natural Resources Canada, “Guide sur les chauffe-eau” (Water Heater Guide)Office of Energy Efficiency, revised October 2012, Cat. No. M144-243/2012F-PDF · pp. 7 and 15 · consulted on November 10, 2026
Natural Resources Canada, “Heat pump water heaters” pageENERGY STAR, certified products · page modified March 19, 2025 · consulted on November 10, 2026
Régie du bâtiment du Québec, explanatory booklet“Principaux changements apportés au Code de construction du Québec, Chapitre III – Plomberie”, November 2024 · article 2.6.1.12, stored water at 60 °C or more · consulted on November 10, 2026